Rediff Navigator News

Capital Buzz

Commentary

Crystal Ball

Dear Rediff

The Rediff Poll

The Rediff Special

The States

Yeh Hai India!

Commentary/Saisuresh Sivaswamy

Growing lawlessness in Bombay will be Sena-BJP's Achilles heel

If Bombay is fast acquiring the reputation quite akin to the killing fields of Bihar, the state government is losing its reputation for efficiency equally quickly. And judging by the current pace of the slide in the law and order situation, the city's police commissioner may not be the only one to find himself without a job.

The dynamics of running a cash-rich state like Maharashtra are quite different from those of running 'normal' states. The affluence that is on display attracts not only migrant labour, but even excessive attention from the underworld that runs a totally parallel economy. All talk of eliminating the parallel system can be either attributed to naivete on the part of the person espousing it, or that it is meant only for public consumption. Without parallel economy, the regular economy of a wealthy state would soon wither.

What governments then do is to maintain that the overt interaction between the two economics is kept to the minimum extent possible, so that there is no unmanageable panic on the part of the public. Different governments adopt different methods towards this end, but the one we have in place is more along the lines of the erstwhile royal patronage.

It is rather a simple method, actually. Just as we had, in medieval times, poet laureates and the like in the royal court, each government has its own preferences in the underworld. The latter is constantly in a state of ferment, which is natural given that the different gangs are constantly endeavouring to do better than the rest. And, it is the backing of the government of the day that keeps the balance. Or keeps the peace.

For there is actually little difference between the respective strengths and weaknesses of the various gangs, a statement which makes sense when you consider that all of them are fugitives from the law. Once official support is given, then the message automatically goes out that any abnormal activity on the part of the rest that could damage the law and order situation, would invite retribution. Occasionally, then, an encounter may be staged, which is more to remind the public of the possibility of lawlessness, but that's about it. The gangs go about their business of extortion prostitution, etc.

But why do politicians need the gangs? Why not eliminate them all would be the natural question. Because criminals, in the eyes of the politicians are a necessary evil, like elections. To fight the latter, you need to befriend the former. Seshan's Law may have won him adulation, but elections in this country still require more funds than sanctioned under law. Elections require more manpower, volunteers if you please, than available. And providing all this, once in five years, is the price the underworld pays to be left alone.

It works, and it worked well. Different parties have different yardsticks to choose their suitor, and these often are an extension of the shibboleths they mouth. Thus, while one party may be soft on a gang that may be perceived to carry clout with the minorities, just because that is their votebank, another may carry the son of the soil claim to the dark regions as well.

And that is the story of how Bombay keeps its wits about itself, it has been a symbiotic relationship all the way.

Trouble seldom erupts, and does only when one of the parties refuses to play ball. As the gangster turned politician Arun Gawli has done, which is causing problems untold to the Shiv Sena-Bharatiya Janata Party government in Maharashtra.

Why did he turn against the hand that had been feeding? Why did he venture into politics, and vie for the very sections identified with the Shiv Sena? These are questions that defy answers, in place of which one can only surmise.

Gawli, it must be noted, is the only ganglord who is left in Bombay, his peers-cum-rivals all being holed up in different havens across the continent where they are apparently safe from the sleuths of the various enforcement agencies. By remaining in Bombay, not only is he vulnerable to attacks from his rivals, but he is also at the mercy of the government in power And having seen the dependence the politicians have on criminals from close quarters, naturally he has decided to turn a disadvantage into an advantage by becoming one of them.

The fallout of this has been twofold. One is that the present government, which had kept the balance of force among the underworld through him, has lost its fulcrum. The other is that he has become a threat, in a political sense, to the very politicians he had been supporting. The result is the bloodbath that Bombay has been witness to of late.

The violence, too, could be the outcome of two factors. One is that Gawli himself is resorting to this route to discredit the government's constituents with an aim to win over that section of the populace that has voted for it. The other is that the other gangs, sensing that Gawli is no more the blue-eyed boy of the administration and that it is a post that is currently vacant, are vying for it by proving their 'mettle'.

It will take some time for the mess to sort itself out, till the gangs sort each other out. But time is not a commodity that is at the easy disposal of the state government, not when an inimical combination is ruling at the Centre. If the Sena-BJP could wriggle out of the Ghatkopar firing controversy by placing the blame on their rivals and a trigger-happy police force, there is nowhere to turn now. The impunity with which corpses are being produced in the death-dance may also sound their own death-knell.

EARLIER INTERVIEWS/REPORTS: 'I believe in some Gandhian values'
Gulshan Kumar killed!
'If policemen kill criminals who are harmful to society I don't see anything wrong with it'

Tell us what you think of this column

Saisuresh Sivaswamy
E-mail


Home | News | Business | Cricket | Movies | Chat
Travel | Life/Style | Freedom | Infotech
Feedback

Copyright 1997 Rediff On The Net
All rights reserved