Home > Business > Business Headline > Report
Stock markets: Investors should stay put
March 15, 2004 13:14 IST
The government's divestment programme through its secondary offerings in six public sector companies (IPCL, CMC, IBP, Dredging Corporation, GAIL and ONGC) received a tremendous response. This is evident from the fact that these offers were oversubscribed several times in most of the issues (notwithstanding the recent fault detected in the stock exchanges software programme that led to the over counting of subscriptions). Through this programme, the government has managed to raise close to Rs 15,000 crore (Rs 150 billion) from the markets, which would help it not only meet its divestment target for FY04 but also assist it in keeping its fiscal deficit under check. | Allotment price | For Retail Investors | Price on March 12, 2004 | % gains over allotment price | Dredging Corp. | 400 | 380 | 557 | 47% | CMC | 485 | 461 | 580 | 26% | GAIL | 195 | 185 | 226 | 22% | IPCL | 170 | 162 | 193 | 20% | ONGC* | 750 | 713 | 801 | 12% | IBP | 620 | 589 | 635 | 8% | *AssumptionThe benefits of this were not restricted to the government alone, as any government is prudent enough (especially before election times) to keep its populace happy and thus ensure its vote bank. The benefit to the retail investor in the government's divestment programme is the fact that investors are allotted the shares at 5 per cent below the offer price finally arrived at through the book-building process. This 5 per cent advantage to the retail investor is in addition to the huge price differential prevailing between the retail offer price and the price of the stock listed on the stock markets (see table above). Moreover, the government made sure that its efforts at sustaining the existing feel-good factor was not affected by the act of any miscreant who intended to play mischief with the markets. This was evident from the government's intervention in the stock markets wherein the divestment minister publicly warned those who intended to form a bear cartel and affect prices of the stocks being offered. This action by the government was a reaction to the continuous drubbing of these public sector stocks on the bourses since the start of 2004 that had led to these stocks losing an average 26 per cent from their highs of 2004 (for example, see IPCL chart below). During the same period, the Sensex lost 10 per cent. However, the governments 'warning' not only took the financial markets by surprise but also led to a sharp bounce back in the shares of the above public offerings. All for the retail investor! However, now that all the issues are closed, the process of allotment of shares is already underway. Considering the attractive price differential prevailing between the allotment price and that prevailing in the stock markets, it is very difficult to convince an investor to hold on to their stock rather than being content with the average 20-25 per cent gains he would fetch by selling his shares on the day of allotment. Thus, the effect of this sudden increase in supply of shares in these stocks post-allotment can be seen in the form of a substantial correction in the stock prices of these stocks during the previous week with the biggest loser being IPCL (down 14 per cent) on twice the volume on the bourses as compared to the first week of the current month (see chart above). Going forward, a similar kind of investor behaviour cannot be ruled out in the case of other stocks also. However, it must be noted here that this kind of an activity is not restricted to only the secondary offerings but is also valid for new companies that get listed on the bourses, e.g. Indraprastha Gas, TV Today, et cetera. This act of selling a stock, which is in demand, to earn profits in the first few days of its allotment/listing, is termed as 'flipping' in stock market parlance. However, we must point out that for long-term investors, this should not be a cause for concern if the investor has invested in an IPO on the basis of the fundamentals of the stock. Thus, if the company has a sound business model and transparent management, capable of delivering and increasing shareholder value, then instead of getting satisfied with 20-25 per cent returns, stay put! Equitymaster.com is one of India's premier finance portals. The web site offers a user-friendly portfolio tracker, a weekly buy/sell recommendation service and research reports on India's top companies.
|