Home > Cricket > PTI > Report

ICC not being fair to Murali: Prasanna

April 30, 2004 19:25 IST

Former Test off-spinner Erapalli Prasanna says the International Cricket Council should take the blame for the messy issue of suspect bowling action and it is unfair to haul up Sri Lankan offie Muthiah Muralitharan now when he is on the verge of making history.

Commenting on the chucking controversy, which made headlines again after Muralitharan was reported recently, the Indian legend said it is unfair to put any bowler under scrutiny after he has played years of international cricket.

"Without going into Muralitharan's doosra, I would like to say don't blame any bowler for suspect action after he has played 80-90 Tests and been on the scene for 10 years or more," Prasanna, who along with Bishen Singh Bedi, B S Chandrashekar and S Venkataraghavan formed the famous spin quartet, said on Friday.

"If at all there was any problem, it should have been dealt with at the early stages. To subject a bowler to such tests when he is on the verge of making history, it is ridiculous.

"Things like 'biomechanics' is just jargon. I think the ICC should take much of the blame [for the present state of things]," he said.

Prasanna, who mesmerized batsmen with his teasing off breaks in the sixties and seventies, said the psychological aspect of why a bowler chucks should be studied in detail rather than by the biomechanical factor.

"We must try and find out why a bowler chucks. We must understand the psychology of the bowler by asking if he is under any pressure or he is gaining any unfair advantage by bowling such a delivery," Prasanna said.

Prasanna, who now lives in Kolkata, expressed bemusement at the interpretation of the law with regard to illegal deliveries and called for a change in the process of dealing with the same.

"I am surprised as to where these degrees have come from," the 63-year-old said, referring to the biomechanics' report on Muralitharan.

The report said the Sri Lankan straightened his arm by 14 degrees as against the permissible five degrees.

"To my knowledge, the Laws of Cricket do not talk about any degree. If the arm straightens, by any degree, then it is illegal.

"If there is any amendment to the Law, I do not know. In my vocabulary, a deviation is a deviation," he said.

The former great, however, disagreed that an off-spinner cannot bowl an away going delivery.

"My friend, have a heart! In our days, too, we used to bowl the floater, the drifter and such away going deliveries. Doosra is a modern terminology.

"There is no reason why an off-spinner cannot take the ball away from the batsman if he can impart enough spin to it," said the former player, who played in 49 Tests and took 189 wickets.

Prasanna said it would be more sensible if the experts study the video of the particular delivery over which the umpires had doubts instead of asking the bowler to reproduce the same in the nets.

"When I was a member of the ICC's Illegal Deliveries Committee -- I don't know if I am still there or not because I have not received any communication from them so far – I suggested that the umpire, when he has a doubt about the bowler's action, make a note of which over and how it happened and report it to the committee. Subsequently, the video of that particular ball could be studied," he said.

Recalling an instance when he was invited to London to watch Harbhajan Singh's remodeled action a few years ago, Prasanna asked, "Do you think any bowler experienced enough will show his weakness after you have told him you are going to test him."

Asked if the onset of television replays coloured the way of looking at bowling actions as such, he replied: "TV is there to help people enjoy -- those who cannot go to the stadium and secondly for the benefit of commentators and umpires to watch replays."

Prasanna also favoured the on-field umpire making decisions instead of experts giving their opinion after studying the videos.

"He [the umpire] is supposed to conduct the game according to the laws and is empowered to take [necessary] action," he said.


Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Write us a letter
Discuss this article



Related Stories


India press for victory

Dravid puts India in command

Plunder in Pindi



People Who Read This Also Read


This team will not yield: Sourav

PCB upset by report leak

Windies-England ODI washed out








© Copyright 2004 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.











Copyright © 2004 rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.